Banking + Finance

With both individuals and corporations taking a close look at their financial well-being in 2023, HundredX looks to The Crowd to understand what real people think of their banks, credit cards, and payment apps. By analyzing 85,000 pieces of feedback on almost 100 brands shared in 2022, HundredX can better understand people’s financial habits in 2023. We find:

  • Payments Usage Intent increases are widespread among most age and income groups. Over the past few months, the biggest increase came from users over the age of 60. 
  • The strong outlook for Payments relative to Banks seems to justify big banks’ efforts to create a digital wallet payment system to compete with Apple Pay, Google Pay, and PayPal.
  • Over the past few months, the number of households with income under $100K saying they will use banks and payment platforms more has skyrocketed.
  • Ohio-based bank KeyBank saw the single largest jump in Usage Intent¹ since September, seemingly getting credit for investments that have enabled customers to open new accounts in near real-time.


More customers plan to use their banks, credit cards, and payments platforms more now compared to the summer months. Usage Intent for Banks, Credit Card Companies, and Payments appears to be trending upward since September 2022, with Payments flat from November to December. Even so, Payments Usage Intent climbed 5% from August to December, easily outpacing the increase for Banks and Credit Card Companies. 


Usage Intent reflects the percentage of customers who plan to use a specific brand more during the next 12 months minus the percentage that intends to use less.

With Usage Intent positive and growing quickly, Payments looks like it is positioned to gain share in the broader financial ecosystem. It’s no wonder big banks are increasingly interested in digital payments.
The Wall Street Journal recently reported that Early Warning Services (EWS), the parent company of the popular payment app Zelle, plans to launch a new digital wallet service later this year. EWS is owned by a consortium of seven of the biggest banks in the U.S. -- JPMorgan Chase, Bank of America, Wells Fargo, U.S. Bank, PNC, Truist, and Capital One. The banks seemingly want a piece of the digital wallet pie, currently filled by Apple Pay, Google Pay and PayPal. 

Never too old for new technology – Payments Usage Intent is surging

Indeed, Payments seemingly appeal to most income and age demographics. While Usage Intent decreased for households making more than $200,000 a year over the past three months, it increased for all other income groups. Households making under $100K have both the highest Usage Intent and increase in intent for Payments, and it appears age plays a factor.

Customers aged 18-29 have the highest Usage Intent for Payments. Younger customers are more plugged into the digital world and more ready and willing to adopt new technologies. A 2021 survey by payments company GoCardless found more than half of Americans aged 18-40 make a digital payment at least once per day.

Interestingly, while Usage Intent is lowest for people aged 60 and above, it’s also grown more for this age group than others over the past three months, rising about 8%. Comments from older HundredX feedback providers show people over 60 are willing to embrace new technologies. 
“PayPal is very functional, easy to use and necessary these days,” one person over 60 said recently.  Another person over 60 said of a payments platform, “Being older it took me time to navigate but I have it now for online shopping.”

Banks and Credit Cards usage intent rising, though mixed by income

Meanwhile, HundredX found that among Banks and Credit Card Companies Usage Intent is rising overall but varies by household income. While a range of factors drives consumer spending activity, it appears the recent slowdown in spending on durable goods (from 8% vs. last year in September to 3% in November) aligns with the decline in bank and credit card intent 2-4 months earlier. We will continue to watch for whether the recent improvement in usage intent is reflected in better growth in spending on durable goods in the coming months.

Households making the most ($200K+ per year) have the highest Credit Card Companies Usage Intent, followed by households making between $100K-$199K, and then those making under $100K. However, Usage Intent is dipping in the last few months for the wealthiest households and rising for the other income brackets.


Meanwhile, Usage Intent among all income brackets is negative for Banks but has seen significant improvement in recent months for households making less than $100K per year. Since August 2022, Usage Intent jumped by 7%, from -11% up to -4% in December among that group. Over the past month, however, Banks saw a decline in Usage Intent among households making $100K-$199K and over $200K.


That decline for the wealthier households highlights an issue the Wall Street Journal recently reported on – wealthy customers are moving money out of banks and their low-yield savings accounts into higher-yielding types of accounts. According to the WSJ, deposits at Bank of America’s wealth unit, which caters to high-net-worth customers, fell 17% in 2022. Deposits in the bank’s consumer unit only fell 0.6%.

Moving the Most

While Banks, Credit Card Companies, and Payments broadly saw small to moderate Usage Intent improvements over the past three months, some individual companies saw significant upwards movement.

Since September, KeyBank saw its Usage Intent rise by 15%, with the largest jump monthly jump (9%) from September to October. Headquartered in Ohio, KeyBank operates more than 1,000 branches and 40,000 ATMs across the U.S. Over the past three months, customers’ sentiment towards several of the bank’s features improved significantly, including towards its Website/App (+18%), Associate Attitude (+15%), Service Speed (+12%), Fees (+11%), and Checkings & Savings (+10%).


“Love [KeyBank] and love the ease of their website and app,” one person told HundredX recently.


In late September, KeyBank announced it expanded its partnership with software vendor Oracle to modernize its underwriting workflow. The improvements enable KeyBank customers to open a new checking, savings, or credit card account in near real-time. Since that announcement, we see customers feel much more positively about KeyBank’s website and app.


HundredX measures sentiment towards a driver of customer satisfaction as the percentage of customers who view a factor as a reason they liked the brand or product minus the percentage who see the same factor as a negative.


As the financial uncertainties of 2023 unfold, HundredX will continue following customers’ intent to use their banks, credit cards, and payment apps and which companies are best positioned to take advantage.


  1. All metrics presented, including Net Usage Intent (Usage Intent), and Net Positive Percent / Sentiment are presented on a trailing three-month basis unless otherwise noted. 

Strategy Made Smarter


HundredX works with a variety of companies and their investors to answer some of the most important strategy questions in business:

  • Where are customers "migrating"?
  • What are they saying they will use more of in the next 12 months?
  • What are the key drivers of their purchase decisions and financial outcomes?


Current clients see immediate benefits across multiple areas including strategy, finance, operations, pricing, investing, and marketing.


Our insights enable business leaders to define and identify specific drivers and decisions enabling them to grow their market share.


Please contact our team to learn more about which businesses across 75 industries are best positioned with customers and the decisions you can make to grow your brand’s market share.

####


HundredX is a mission-based data and insights provider . HundredX does not make investment recommendations. However, we believe in the wisdom of the crowd to inform the outlook for businesses and industries. For more info on specific drivers of customer satisfaction, other companies within 75+ other industries we cover, or if you'd like to learn more about using Data for Good, please reach out: https://hundredx.com/contact .

Share This Article

Hollywood Strikes and Price Hikes Dim Streaming Enthusiasm

By Todd Cook • September 28, 2023
The streaming industry has made progress but still has further to go navigating one of its biggest hurdles in years – production delays for movies and shows resulting from Hollywood writers and actors going on strike. To make up for the hole, platforms have turned to alternatives such as more international content, unscripted / reality shows and live events streaming on multiple channels simultaneously. At the same time, industry heavy hitters like Disney+, Hulu, and Netflix tweaked their prices, which annoyed customers already grappling with inflation. Viewers seemingly haven’t been satisfied with the content substitutions and plan changes, as the strikes and price adjustments seem to have contributed to a 1% dip in Usage Intent ¹,² across the streaming industry that began in May through August. It appears ending the strikes and getting new content back on the platforms needs to be a top strategic priority, particularly for Disney and Netflix, who have seen the biggest recent drops in Usage Intent. The Writers Guild (WGA) ended its strike September 27, while the Screen Actor’s Guild (SAG-AFTRA) is expected to meet with studios to find a resolution soon. The industry hopes it can next reach agreements with the actors who are still on strike soon. Analyzing more than 100,000 pieces of customer feedback across 23 video streaming services, we find:

Swoosh vs. Storm: Nike’s DTC Channel holding its ground but showing some cracks

By Todd Cook • September 27, 2023
Apparel and athleticwear retailers have seen material slowdowns in their businesses amid rising inflation and the looming resumption of student loan repayments, raising the level of debate about the health of Nike’s business heading into its Q1 2024 earnings report. Insights from “The Crowd” of real shoppers indicates Nike’s business should have seen some downward pressure in recent months but appears more resilient than most others. Despite the economic headwinds, we find Nike's direct-to-consumer (DTC) channel has bucked the trend with a modest 2% uptick in Purchase Intent ¹ , ² year-over-year in August for the Nike Store, unlike retail partners DSW and Foot Locker who are witnessing dips in both Purchase Intent and reported US sales. However, HundredX did see Purchase Intent for people under 40 dip 1% in August vs. July 2023, the first decline in over a year. This indicates demand growth is starting to crack among Gen Z and millennials, important customer groups for the sportswear company. While young adults still love the swoosh, the impending crunch on disposable income might pose a problem for Nike in the coming months. Analyzing more than 260,000 pieces of feedback across apparel, fashion, and footwear stores over the last year, including more than 20,000 on just Nike, we find:

Diet soda drinkers seemingly unfazed by aspartame report

By Todd Cook • September 22, 2023
Diet soda drinkers seemingly unfazed by aspartame report